Salerno Auto Body Since 1959 · Family Ran Since 1959 · 24/7 Drop Off · Top Tier Collision Shop in the NYC Metro Area Salerno Auto Body · 451 Lorimer Street, Brooklyn, NY 11206 1-800-558-8093

New York Claim Guide · Since 1959

How Insurance Claims Work at a Body Shop in New York

Most drivers only deal with a collision claim once every few years. Here is how the process works from the moment you report damage through pickup, and how Salerno Auto Body handles the paperwork with all insurance companies at 451 Lorimer Street in Brooklyn.

Send photos of the damage — we text you back fast

Step 1: Choose Your Body Shop First

After a crash or storm damage, you do not have to wait for an insurer to assign a repair facility. Under New York Insurance Law § 2610, an insurance company providing collision or comprehensive coverage cannot require you to have repairs done at a particular shop. Once you open a claim and get a claim number, you can direct your vehicle straight to Salerno Auto Body at 451 Lorimer Street, Brooklyn, NY 11206.

For the full statute details, see your right to choose your repair shop in New York, or can I choose my own body shop with GEICO.

Step 2: Send Photos or Bring the Car In

If the car is drivable, drive over or use our 24 Hour Drop Off at 451 Lorimer Street — we are open 24/7 to accept and safeguard vehicles with keys. Collision repairs are not 24-hour repairs. You can also text damage photos to (718) 395-6672 or email photos to salernoautobody@gmail.com, or call 1-800-558-8093 if you need a Free Tow from the accident scene for collision repairs (Manhattan to Montauk).

Step 3: Inspection, Agreed Price, and Hidden-Damage Supplements

An insurer’s initial photo or walk-around estimate only covers visible outer damage. Once our I-CAR Trained Technicians disassemble the damaged area, hidden parts or mounting damage often appear. When that happens, we photograph the newly exposed damage and send a supplement request directly to the insurance adjuster.

Under New York Insurance Regulation 64 (11 NYCRR 216.7), the insurer is expected to negotiate in good faith toward an agreed price for the repair. We handle that back-and-forth and keep you updated without making generic time promises before the damage is inspected.

Step 4: Deductibles, Total Loss Checks, and Pickup

If your repair goes forward under your own collision or comprehensive policy, your deductible is typically paid when you pick up the finished car, and the insurer pays the rest of the covered repair. (If the vehicle is declared a total loss by the insurer rather than repaired, the insurer handles total-loss settlement directly with you under your policy terms.)

We work with all insurance companies and handle the claim paperwork from start to finish. See also insurance claims at Salerno, car accident repair checklist, and getting an estimate.

Salerno Auto Body logo surrounded by logos of major insurance companies, including GEICO, Progressive, The Hartford, and USAA
We work with all major insurance companies.
Cars being repaired in the bays at Salerno Auto Body, a Brooklyn collision repair and auto body shop, including a vehicle on a lift
Inside the auto body shop in Brooklyn: cars in the collision repair bays at Salerno Auto Body, including a vehicle on a lift.
The Salerno Service Station Since 1959 sign over the open bays of the auto body shop at 451 Lorimer Street in Williamsburg, Brooklyn
The Salerno Service Station sign — Since 1959 — over the open bays at 451 Lorimer Street, an auto body shop for Brooklyn collision repair.

Send photos for an estimate

Send photos of the damage — we text you back fast

Common New York Insurance Claim Questions

Do I have to get multiple estimates before choosing a body shop?

No. In New York, you do not have to drive around collecting three estimates before picking your shop. You can choose Salerno Auto Body first, bring the car to 451 Lorimer Street or send photos, and we work with the insurer on the inspection and repair plan. This is general information, not legal advice.

What happens if the body shop finds hidden damage after taking the car apart?

When hidden collision damage shows up during teardown, the shop documents it with photos and submits a supplement to the insurance company. Under 11 NYCRR 216.7, insurers negotiate in good faith toward an agreed repair price. We handle those supplement filings and adjuster follow-ups for you.

When and where do I pay my deductible?

If your policy has a collision or comprehensive deductible, it is normally collected by the body shop when you pick up the repaired vehicle, while the insurer pays the covered balance under the claim. How your claim check is issued depends on your policy and whether another driver was at fault.

Can my insurance company tell me where I must fix my car?

No. Under New York Insurance Law § 2610(a), an insurer providing collision or comprehensive coverage cannot require repairs at a particular shop. You have the right to choose your repair shop. This is general information, not legal advice.

Will you handle my insurance claim?

Yes. We work with all insurance companies and we handle your claim from start to finish — from the estimate through the repair. You still choose the shop. If you have GEICO or another insurer, call 1-800-558-8093 or text (718) 395-6672 and we will walk you through the next step.

Call 1-800-558-8093 Text Us Photos Email Us Photos